Florida Keys News
Saturday, April 14, 2012
Add to FacebookAdd to Twitter
Millennium cruise ship gives educational tour

Key West civic leaders and city officials were among the tour-takers Friday to get an up-close view of how one cruise ship calling on the Southernmost City manages its sewage, wastewater and other ways it interacts with the environment.

While aspects of Royal Caribbean's Millennium cruise ship's disposal and recycling system impressed some, the field trip did little to settle questions about the most crucial cruise ship question facing Key West, the potential for widening the channel the ships traverse en route to the island. Discussion of that topic, industry and civic representatives agreed, was not the purpose of the field trip.

"We wanted people to see what we actually do, and not go by rumor or hearsay, and get it straight from us," Royal Caribbean spokesman Rich Pruitt said. "We wanted them to hear our words and get down below and see what actions we are taking."

Pruitt's presentation outlined the specific types of waste that are generated on board a ship like the Millennium, ranging from sewage -- the company's standard is to release it after treatment 12 miles from shore rather than the 4 miles industry conventions allow -- to silver nitrate as a byproduct from photographs taken aboard.

"We will recycle everything that is recyclable, and if we can't recycle it, we will find a place to put it," Pruitt said.

The invitation-only event was attended by reporters, members of the Key West Chamber of Commerce, environmental advocacy organizations Last Stand and Reef Relief, City Commissioner Tony Yaniz, city Ports Director Jim Fitton and two Coast Guard representatives.

Launched in the year 2000, the Malta-flagged Millennium is 984 feet long and carries as many as 1,190 passengers and a crew of 900. It's smaller than the newer Oasis class of ships, which exceed 1,100 feet in length and are not expected to be able to come to Key West. That's due to problems relating to crosswinds in the island's channel, considered too narrow to safely navigate the bigger vessels. The channel is 300 feet wide, and advocates would like it dredged to 450 feet.

As the industry moves toward larger ships, Pruitt said, it is likely that smaller vessels will be eventually be working other routes, and that the big ones will be making the Caribbean runs that would include Key West as a port of call.

The Millennium's captain, Alevropoulos Emmanouil, became involved in a discussion of the ship's maneuvering capabilities, noting that modern technology allows the potential for short stops and other maneuvers never dreamed possible before. Propellers can turn 180 degrees within their enclosure areas, meaning the ship itself might not need to make turns for tight spots.

He stopped short of saying that any such benefits exist for the Dream class of ships.

Shirley Freeman, former mayor of Monroe County, who heads the advisory committee that is helping city commissioners choose a new city manager for Key West, noted that channel widening is a separate issue from recycling and waste management considerations. But she saw interesting future possibilities after hearing what the captain had to say.

"I was greatly impressed and intrigued by the way the captain described the maneuverability of these ships forward and backward and sideways and how they can stop on a dime, in one minute, from normal speed," Freeman said. "That's pretty good and tells me you don't need a wider channel. We will let the technology take care of that aspect as it improves."

Freeman said she remembers when cruise ships were blamed for discharging trash in the water years ago, and that she was pleased by the amount of progress made, as evidenced by Friday's tour.

"I remember when everything was dumped overboard -- raw sewage, plastic, just what we used to pick up off the beach here, things that said Royal Caribbean on them. But I am talking about the 1980s. They have gone from putting everything in the water to some pretty nice systems. They're sure way ahead of the city of Key West."

Last Stand's Mark Songer said he was not surprised by the level of environmental concern and good stewardship practices displayed.

"Hearing that international standards are 4 nautical miles outside the land for treated discharge and that they go 12 before they do anything, and the advanced wastewater treatment, I think generally the cruise industry is doing the right thing with their waste disposal," Songer said.

He and other attendees were also impressed by the practice of grinding up leftover food and jettisoning it 12 miles from shore, even though not required to do so.

Fresh water and other waste is dispersed only after the ships reach a speed of 6 knots, leaving no pockets or trails in the water because the spread disperses easily.

Songer also did not expect the visit to shed light on the channel-widening issue.

"There are solutions besides drilling a bigger hole in the ground," he said. "We are in favor of protecting the National Marine Sanctuary. And if we can have the bigger ones call on us without digging a bigger hole in the ground, we are interested in studying it. But if we were looking at a significant increase in the number of passengers, we need to understand best management practices for how to properly entertain that many guests."

jdesantis@keysnews.com

Share your thoughts and opinions related to this posting. Login or register to post comments. More Info

According to MARPOL

According to MARPOL regulations, if they're far enough offshore they can dump anything but plastic. That's probably the only thing they're recycling. Many, many cruise ships cut through the FL Straights en route to Mexico without even stopping in KW. Trash is bad enough but food and even treated sewage (and it IS legal to discharge untreated!) create nutrients in the ocean causing algae blooms, even red tide. Algae smothers reefs and causes Eutrophication and other imbalances in the ecosystem like jellyfish blooms- remember last August? It's not a question of what one ship or one company does once a week as they eject garbage and sewage near our fragile reef, it's the entire industry and hundreds of ships doing this on a weekly basis. If our reef is dead, our tourist industry dies too. There will be no more cruise ships and they will not have to pay the price forthe damage we allowed them to incur. http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:MARPOL_73-78_Instructions.png Sewage under MARPOL annex IV can be dumped at a distance of 12mi offshore or 3mi if treated. However, the US is not one of the countries adhering to Annex IV.

12 miles off shore?

Sounds like they have the means to reduce the impact of their waste, but we don't know how well this is carried out. We do NOT need more garbage, treated or ground up, in our near shore waters or in the ocean at all. Where's the data on how much waste? How many ships a week do this?

here we go!

Certainly no surprise the cruise industry is trying win over the opposition by tooting their own horns. I'm just saying, folks please do not get complacent over this channel widening issue. . .the cruise industry has lots of money & tools at their disposal. If we dont pay attention, our city officials will become mesmerized by all the "shiny objects" & BS thrown their way. . .then they'll be telling us how great the ships are & we must widen the channel.

"Educational Tour," my butt!

Just more cruise industry lobbying set up by Port Director Jim Fitton-- who should be leaving town, fast on the heels of ex-city manager Jim Scholl. This guy doesn't listen to the public and to the commission any more than Scholl did. He persists in increasing the size and number of cruise ships visiting our tiny port, despite a public hue and cry against the outrageous press of uncontrollable pedestrian and vehicular congestion.

It's time for one of our city commissioners-- perhaps the only sane one, Tony Yaniz-- to call for a halt to cruise ships in our small harbor. The public will be solidly behind you, Tony.

Let's insist on a public referendum. Now, before lobbying leads to channel widening.

Roving Rust Buckets

Roving rust buckets purging their excrement off our shore everyday sure sounds like a bad idea. Treated? Sure it is. Pull my other leg; it plays jingle bells. This island community has sold its soul to the devil four times over. The arts, fishing industry, and historically significant sites all suffer so cargo ships full of clowns can be belched onto Duval Street to get drunk and buy t-shirts. Select few reap the profits at the expensive of the community.

Factual Errors require correction

The ship in question is the "Celebrity Millenium," not Royal Caribbean. Although Celebrity was acquired by Royal, it maintains a separate identity, just as Cunard is separate from Carnival.

Much more importantly, the passenger capacity on the Millenium is over 2,000, not 1190 - as stated in the article. http://www.celebritycruises.com/explore/ships/detail.do?shipCode=ML

Celebrity Millenium

I was just getting ready to say the same thing. It's the Celebrity Millenium, not Royal Caribbean Millenium. Royal Caribbean Cruises, Ltd (RCCL), is the holding company, not the cruise line. RCCL also owns Royal Caribbean International (RCI), another individual cruise line under RCCL. It's like referring to the Concordia as Carnival instead of the real cruise line, Costa.

Maybe I like this...

Let's start referring to the "Carnival Concordia"
Available Only in the Electronic Edition
Sunday, May 26, 2013 -
Saturday, May 25, 2013 -
Friday, May 24, 2013 -
Thursday, May 23, 2013 -
Wednesday, May 22, 2013 -