Florida Keys News
Monday, April 16, 2012
Add to FacebookAdd to Twitter
County to vote on boat mooring rules

George Neugent can't wait for Wednesday's Monroe County Commission meeting.

The commissioner isn't eager to sit through hours of mundane government business, he just wants the county to finally proceed with a series of long-awaited test rules for boats moored off the Florida Keys.

"It has been a frustrating experience," Neugent said of the delay in implementing rules that would be effective until 2014. "We know what needs to be done, but there has been a reluctance to move forward. It's been a mess and it needs to be cleaned up. People are still going to be able to live on their boats and to cruise. The only thing this does is help eliminate irresponsible boating."

The commission is scheduled to vote on a draft of the rules, and if approved, send them to the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission (FWC) board for approval at its June meeting in West Palm Beach. Then the County Commission would vote on them again before they're enforced.

The proposed rules include banning non-motorized floating structures, requiring proof of regular sewage pump-out, annual Coast Guard Auxiliary safety inspections and tagging -- and eventually removing -- vessels at risk of sinking. The rules would also set up no-anchoring buffer zones around managed mooring fields in Marathon and Key West.

The rules are part of a pilot program with the FWC, which wants to give local governments more control over live-aboard and cruising vessels. FWC is concerned about derelict and abandoned vessels, pollution and water quality.

The rules would affect Key West Harbor, Boca Chica Basin off Stock Island and Sunset Key off Key Largo. After 2014, the FWC would review the rules and decide whether to ask the state Legislature to make them permanent.

The rules have been delayed because they have met with some resistance from the live-aboard and cruising communities.

Neugent is a member of the Florida Keys National Marine Sanctuary Advisory Council, which has been supportive of the FWC pilot program. Neugent, Sanctuary Superintendent Sean Morton and sanctuary representatives plan to meet with FWC and state Department of Environmental Protection officials in Clearwater next month to discuss creating more managed mooring fields off the Keys, Neugent said.

"The only way to clean up some of the areas is by requiring pump-out and having managed mooring fields," Neugent said. "It is the only way to deal with the derelict vessel issue, which is costing the county $273,000 a year in boater improvement funds."

The boaters fear the pilot program gives FWC officers too much discretion. They reminded the commission at previous meetings that these boats or floating structures are people's homes and businesses, saying they should be treated with respect. They have requested some kind of hearing procedure before removal, which could be included in the rules.

There has also been opposition to prohibiting floating structures, as there are several floating businesses, bait shops and watersports barges around Wisteria Island in Key West Harbor.

Don Bilodeau, who has operated the same floating bait shop off Wisteria Island for the past 10 years, has voiced opposition to the rules about prohibiting floating structures. His bait shop has never sunk nor damaged the seafloor, he said.

tohara@keysnews.com

Share your thoughts and opinions related to this posting. Login or register to post comments. More Info

jealous?

...landlubbers are always jealous and afraid of the people strong enough to live on the sea.they hide in their little shacks blaming the pollution they spew on the land on the few people who have learned how to live in harmony with the earth.

jealous?

...landlubbers are always jealous and afraid of the people strong enough to live on the sea.they hide in their little shacks blaming the pollution they spew on the land on the few people who have learned how to live in harmony with the earth.

Tourist boaters are already moving on

I personally know of cruising boaters who are already avoiding the Keys or moving on because of the unfriendly attitude exemplified by communities and folks like you. Speaking of ignorant, it is already illegal to pumpout sewage in the Keys and has been for years. The proposed law is about harassing anchored boaters by requiring proofs of pumpout, which they won't have if arriving from anywhere else they are not required. Many boats, like mine, don't require pumpouts because I have a legal composting system. Yes, marinas don't want people to pumpout, but why not have the same proof requirements for boats there? Why not require safety inspections for stored boats at anchor with no people onboard? The stored boats are the ones most likely to wash ashore or sink, because nobody is watching them. Of course stored boats and boats in marinas won't be subject to inspection because they are owned by Keys residents, who don't want the hassle they want to subject anchored visitors to. You seem to want us all to go away and we will if treated like this, along with our dollars.

you just don't get it and

you just don't get it and it's too complicated to explain it all to you. nobody is picking on you so if you want to pick up your toys and leave then please do so, but you don't know all of what's already been in the works for quite some time now... you've made far too many wrong assumptions without knowing all the facts.

New rules not needed

There are existing regulations that cover all of these issues. The majority of that cost to remove derelict vessels was for commercial vessels not covered by these new regulations. There will still be derelicts ignoring the existing rules. These new regulations will just harass legitimate tourist boaters who want to visit the Keys and spend some time at anchor. Plus, several of them, like vessel safety checks, will be challenged in court and found illegal. Like car inspection and pollution rules--that is a statewide issue that is not covered in this Pilot Program law, which states that the county may regulate "anchoring." The law says nothing about pumpouts, which are already required by law, or safety inspections for equipment, that is already required by existing law. If the current law isn't being enforced, why should we expect additional regulations to be enforced?

would you rather the Coast

would you rather the Coast Guard themselves conduct the safety inspections because they will issue citations for each violation and that will get expensive real quick? they have every right to board any vessel at any time to conduct those inspections. sounds to me like you are one of those that might not pass an inspection, and that can put other vessels or people in danger. if people refuse or cannot afford to maintain their vessels they need to find an aternative place to live.

I have been inspected

I have been boarded and inspected by the CG five times, and have always passed with flying colors. I am a cruising sailor who has spent thousands of tourist dollars while visiting the Keys. These onerous anchoring regulations will just chase away upstanding boaters like myself who don't feel we should be discriminated against and harassed because we prefer to anchor. Why don't these new safety and pumpout rules apply to stored boats and boats in marinas too? Because, those writing the rules look down on people who like to anchor out, like me, and apparently they don't want me visiting or spending money in Keys harbors.

maybe it's best if you don't

maybe it's best if you don't come back being that you are ignorant. we have far too many ignorant tourists already... don't need or want another one. marinas do require boats docked there to use a pump out system and most marinas have them onsite rather than relying upon a pump- out boat. i don't know of one marina that allows vessels to dump sewage into their waters... do you, because that's illegal? as for inspections... none of the more reputable marinas will allow derelict vessels to tie up because they are a safety issue and usually unsightly. any half decent "cruising sailor" will welcome these regulations so they won't have to deal with unsafe and unsightly vessels. thanks for visiting and spending your money... now move along!
More Florida Keys Headlines
Wednesday, May 22, 2013
3 comments
Wednesday, May 22, 2013
2 comments
Wednesday, May 22, 2013
Wednesday, May 22, 2013
3 comments
Wednesday, May 22, 2013
1 comment
Available Only in the Electronic Edition